Nonhomologous End Joining Is More Important Than Proton Linear Energy Transfer in Dictating Cell Death


      This study seeks to identify biological factors that may yield a therapeutic advantage of proton therapy versus photon therapy. Specifically, we address the role of nonhomologous end-joining (NHEJ) and homologous recombination (HR) in the survival of cells in response to clinical photon and proton beams.

      Methods and Materials

      We irradiated HT1080, M059K (DNA-PKcs+/+), and HCC1937 human cancer cell lines and their isogenic counterparts HT1080-shDNA-PKcs, HT1080-shRAD51IND, M059J (DNA-PKcs–/–), and HCC1937-BRCA1 (BRCA1 complemented) to assess cell clonogenic survival and γ-H2AX radiation-induced foci. Cells were irradiated with either clinically relevant photons or 1 of 3 proton linear energy transfer (LET) values.


      Our results indicate that NHEJ deficiency is more important in dictating cell survival than proton LET. Cells with disrupted HR through BRCA1 mutation showed increased radiosensitivity only for high-LET protons whereas RAD51 depletion showed increased radiosensitivity for both photons and protons. DNA double strand breaks, assessed by γ-H2AX radiation-induced foci, showed greater numbers after 24 hours in cells exposed to higher LET protons. We also observed that NHEJ-deficient cells were unable to repair the vast majority of double strand breaks after 24 hours.


      BRCA1 mutation significantly sensitizes cells to protons, but not photons. Loss of NHEJ renders cells hypersensitive to radiation, whereas the relative importance of HR increases with LET across several cell lines. This may be attributable to the more clustered damage induced by higher LET protons, which are harder to repair through NHEJ. This highlights the importance of tumor biology in dictating treatment modality and suggests BRCA1 as a potential biomarker for proton therapy response. Our data also support the use of pharmacologic inhibitors of DNA repair to enhance the sensitivity to different radiation types, although this raises issues for normal tissue toxicity.
      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment
      ASTRO Member Login
      ASTRO Members, full access to the journal is a member benefit. Use your society credentials to access all journal content and features.
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect


        • Mavragani I.V.
        • Nikitaki Z.
        • Souli M.P.
        • et al.
        Complex DNA damage: A route to radiation-induced genomic instability and carcinogenesis.
        Cancers (Basel). 2017; 9: E91
        • Hada M.
        • Georgakilas A.G.
        Formation of clustered DNA damage after high-let irradiation: A review.
        J Radiat Res. 2008; 49: 203-210
        • Carter R.J.
        • Nickson C.M.
        • Thompson J.M.
        • et al.
        Complex DNA damage induced by high linear energy transfer alpha-particles and protons triggers a specific cellular DNA damage response.
        Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2018; 100: 776-784
        • Lorat Y.
        • Timm S.
        • Jakob B.
        • et al.
        Clustered double-strand breaks in heterochromatin perturb DNA repair after high linear energy transfer irradiation.
        Radiother Oncol. 2016; 121: 154-161
        • Friedland W.
        • Schmitt E.
        • Kundrat P.
        • et al.
        Comprehensive track-structure based evaluation of DNA damage by light ions from radiotherapy-relevant energies down to stopping.
        Sci Rep. 2017; 7: 45161
        • Asaithamby A.
        • Hu B.
        • Chen D.J.
        Unrepaired clustered DNA lesions induce chromosome breakage in human cells.
        Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011; 108: 8293-8298
        • Okayasu R.
        • Okada M.
        • Okabe A.
        • et al.
        Repair of DNA damage induced by accelerated heavy ions in mammalian cells proficient and deficient in the non-homologous end-joining pathway.
        Radiat Res. 2006; 165: 59-67
        • Roos W.P.
        • Thomas A.D.
        • Kaina B.
        DNA damage and the balance between survival and death in cancer biology.
        Nat Rev Cancer. 2016; 16: 20-33
        • Löbrich M.
        • Jeggo P.
        A process of resection-dependent nonhomologous end joining involving the goddess artemis.
        Trends Biochem Sci. 2017; 42: 690-701
        • Chang H.H.Y.
        • Pannunzio N.R.
        • Adachi N.
        • et al.
        Non-homologous DNA end joining and alternative pathways to double-strand break repair.
        Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 2017; 18: 495-506
        • Jeggo P.A.
        • Geuting V.
        • Löbrich M.
        The role of homologous recombination in radiation-induced double-strand break repair.
        Radiother Oncol. 2011; 101: 7-12
        • Shibata A.
        Regulation of repair pathway choice at two-ended DNA double-strand breaks.
        Mutat Res. 2017; 803-805: 51-55
        • Grosse N.
        • Fontana A.O.
        • Hug E.B.
        • et al.
        Deficiency in homologous recombination renders mammalian cells more sensitive to proton versus photon irradiation.
        Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2014; 88: 175-181
        • Genet S.C.
        • Maeda J.
        • Fujisawa H.
        • et al.
        Comparison of cellular lethality in DNA repair-proficient or -deficient cell lines resulting from exposure to 70 mev/n protons or 290 mev/n carbon ions.
        Oncol Rep. 2012; 28: 1591-1596
        • Maeda J.
        • Fujii Y.
        • Fujisawa H.
        • et al.
        Hyperthermia-induced radiosensitization in cho wild-type, nhej repair mutant and hr repair mutant following proton and carbon-ion exposure.
        Oncol Lett. 2015; 10: 2828-2834
        • Gerelchuluun A.
        • Manabe E.
        • Ishikawa T.
        • et al.
        The major DNA repair pathway after both proton and carbon-ion radiation is NHEJ, but the HR pathway is more relevant in carbon ions.
        Radiat Res. 2015; 183: 345-356
        • Fontana A.O.
        • Augsburger M.A.
        • Grosse N.
        • et al.
        Differential DNA repair pathway choice in cancer cells after proton- and photon-irradiation.
        Radiother Oncol. 2015; 116: 374-380
        • Allalunis-Turner M.J.
        • Barron G.M.
        • Day 3rd, R.S.
        • et al.
        Isolation of two cell lines from a human malignant glioma specimen differing in sensitivity to radiation and chemotherapeutic drugs.
        Radiat Res. 1993; 134: 349-354
        • Lees-Miller S.P.
        • Godbout R.
        • Chan D.W.
        • et al.
        Absence of p350 subunit of DNA-activated protein kinase from a radiosensitive human cell line.
        Science. 1995; 267: 1183-1185
        • Stecklein S.R.
        • Kumaraswamy E.
        • Behbod F.
        • et al.
        Brca1 and hsp90 cooperate in homologous and non-homologous DNA double-strand-break repair and g2/m checkpoint activation.
        Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012; 109: 13650-13655
        • Bhattacharya S.
        • Srinivasan K.
        • Abdisalaam S.
        • et al.
        Rad51 interconnects between DNA replication, DNA repair and immunity.
        Nucleic Acids Res. 2017; 45: 4590-4605
        • Hojo H.
        • Dohmae T.
        • Hotta K.
        • et al.
        Difference in the relative biological effectiveness and DNA damage repair processes in response to proton beam therapy according to the positions of the spread out bragg peak.
        Radiat Oncol. 2017; 12: 111
        • Liu Q.
        • Ghosh P.
        • Magpayo N.
        • et al.
        Lung cancer cell line screen links fanconi anemia/brca pathway defects to increased relative biological effectiveness of proton radiation.
        Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2015; 91: 1081-1089
        • Wang H.
        • Wang X.
        • Zhang P.
        • et al.
        The ku-dependent non-homologous end-joining but not other repair pathway is inhibited by high linear energy transfer ionizing radiation.
        DNA Repair (Amst). 2008; 7: 725-733
        • Takahashi A.
        • Kubo M.
        • Ma H.
        • et al.
        Nonhomologous end-joining repair plays a more important role than homologous recombination repair in defining radiosensitivity after exposure to high-LET radiation.
        Radiat Res. 2014; 182: 338-344
        • Brown J.M.
        Beware of clinical trials of DNA repair inhibitors.
        Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2019; 103: 1182-1183
        • Isono M.
        • Niimi A.
        • Oike T.
        • et al.
        BRCA1 directs the repair pathway to homologous recombination by promoting 53BP1 dephosphorylation.
        Cell Rep. 2017; 18: 520-532
        • Wang Y.
        • Krais J.J.
        • Bernhardy A.J.
        • et al.
        Ring domain-deficient brca1 promotes PARP inhibitor and platinum resistance.
        J Clin Invest. 2016; 126: 3145-3157
        • DelloRusso C.
        • Welcsh P.L.
        • Wang W.
        • et al.
        Functional characterization of a novel BRCA1-null ovarian cancer cell line in response to ionizing radiation.
        Mol Cancer Res. 2007; 5: 35-45
        • Scully R.
        • Ganesan S.
        • Vlasakova K.
        • et al.
        Genetic analysis of brca1 function in a defined tumor cell line.
        Mol Cell. 1999; 4: 1093-1099
        • Li X.
        • Heyer W.D.
        Homologous recombination in DNA repair and DNA damage tolerance.
        Cell Res. 2008; 18: 99-113
        • Hustedt N.
        • Durocher D.
        The control of DNA repair by the cell cycle.
        Nat Cell Biol. 2016; 19: 1-9
        • Biehs R.
        • Steinlage M.
        • Barton O.
        • et al.
        DNA double-strand break resection occurs during non-homologous end joining in G1 but is distinct from resection during homologous recombination.
        Mol Cell. 2017; 65: 671-684
        • Mackenzie K.J.
        • Carroll P.
        • Martin C.A.
        • et al.
        cGAS surveillance of micronuclei links genome instability to innate immunity.
        Nature. 2017; 548: 461-465
        • Harding S.M.
        • Benci J.L.
        • Irianto J.
        • et al.
        Mitotic progression following DNA damage enables pattern recognition within micronuclei.
        Nature. 2017; 548: 466-470


      Commenting Guidelines

      To submit a comment for a journal article, please use the space above and note the following:

      • We will review submitted comments as soon as possible, striving for within two business days.
      • This forum is intended for constructive dialogue. Comments that are commercial or promotional in nature, pertain to specific medical cases, are not relevant to the article for which they have been submitted, or are otherwise inappropriate will not be posted.
      • We require that commenters identify themselves with names and affiliations.
      • Comments must be in compliance with our Terms & Conditions.
      • Comments are not peer-reviewed.